The German KwK 42/Pak 42 75 mm tank/anti-tank guns were marginally better than the 17 pounder. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. 17 May 2017. Used with the APDS shot, it was capable of defeating all but the thickest armour on German tanks. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. It is approximately 350 inch-pounds out of balance with a round of APCBC in the chamber. In late 1940 design of a replacement was started, and was largely complete by the end of 1941. 162 / 1 and 2. Comparing 88mm KwK L/56 (Tiger I) and 17 pounder might give 17 pounder some advantages in armor penetration. Mainly just who is beefier, more ft/lbs. 42 L/70) baugleich als Panzerjagdkanone ab 1942 im Zweiten Weltkrieg zum Einsatz kam. An unproveable belief in a reality beyond this world. Both High firing,high damage and high accuracy anti-tank guns which one do you guys think is better. At 300 meters, the KwK 43 can finally penetrate the side of the tank, but it's a "limit of rear surface" penetration, a standard where the shell only has to cause damage the rear of the plate, and not actually make it all the way through. „KWK-Strom" das rechnerische Produkt aus Nutzwärme und Stromkennzahl der KWK-Anlage; bei Anlagen, die nicht über Vorrichtungen zur Abwärmeabfuhr verfügen, ist die gesamte Nettostromerzeugung KWK-Strom, 17. Die 7,5-cm-KwK 42 war eine Kampfwagenkanone (kurz: KwK), die mit der Kaliberlänge L/70 als Hauptbewaffnung/ Turmkanone im mittleren Kampfpanzer Panzer V eingebaut wurde, aber auch im Panzer IV/70 unter der Bezeichnung 7,5-cm-PaK 42 L/70(frühere 7,5-cm-Stu.K. The Ordnance Quick-Firing 17-pounder (or just 17-pdr) was a 76.2 mm (3 inch) gun developed by the United Kingdom during World War II.It was used as an anti-tank gun on its own carriage, as well as equipping a number of British tanks. Also I want you guys to Judge these guns from historical standpoint not from a in-game standpoint, WG: "Bricks working as intended. Wikipedia lists muzzle velocity for the "42" at 935 meters/sec (3067 ft/sec) firing AP shot. Velocity, accuracy, flash, shell weight, projectile weight etc etc. Especially considering their abandonment of the 75mm gun for the two tank gun versions of their 88 AA gun. short barreled 88 - posted in Gameplay: Chipmunk_of_Vengeance, on 03 February 2018 - 05:27 PM, said: Im not going by just shell weight or explosive filler, but also muzzle velocity, the the higher the muzzle velocity the more kinetic damage potential that shell is capable of doing. Wight of the two rounds should not differ by much and the QF 17-pounder even has the heavier projectile. „KWKK-Anlagen" KWK-Anlagen, die durch eine thermisch angetriebene Kältemaschine ergänzt sind, 16. Thoughts? But I could be wrong. 76mm with counterweight is balanced when the chamber is loaded. Edit. So a 17-Pounder should be able to do just as much damage as an 8,8cm KwK 36 round. The 8.8 cm Flak 18/36/37/41 (commonly called the eighty-eight) was a German 88 mm anti-aircraft and anti-tank artillery gun from World War II. 35B06: 7.44: 0pcs: 7.5cm KwK 42 L/70 PzKpfw V - Panther> dedicated for Dragon models. The 8.8 cm KwK 36 a.k.a. The D-25T can achieve the same from 1100 meters, or make it clean through the plate from 600 meters. Jahr;Entwicklung der KWKG-Umlage bzw. The 17 pounder was a great gun, no one will take that away, but to say it is the best AT gun of the war is just false. 7.5 cm KwK 42 vs Ordnance QF 17-pounder - posted in General Discussion: Both High firing,high damage and high accuracy anti-tank guns which one do you guys think is better. During this time, please do not edit this article because the current editor might be confused. “17 pounder is balanced with the chamber unloaded and counterweight in place. Mainly just who is beefier, more ft/lbs. A prototype production line was set up that spring, and with the appearance of Tiger I tanks in North Africa, the first 100 prototype 17-pounder anti-tank guns were quickly sent off to help co… The Valentine is not surprising at all. Die 12,8-cm-KwK 44 war eine Kampfwagenkanone (kurz KwK) der deutschen Wehrmacht, die mit der Kaliberlänge L/55 als Turmkanone für den überschweren Panzer VIII „Maus“ konzipiert wurde, aber auch weitgehend baugleich als Panzerjagdkanone (kurz: PjK) mit der Bezeichnung 12,8-cm-PjK 44 als Hauptbewaffnung im schweren Panzerjäger „Jagdtiger“ zum Einsatz kam. 1: A leap of faith. HE can knock off the tracks. That also may not matter if one side used a more effective powder. Betreiber von KWK-Anlagen mit einer elektrischen KWK-Leistung über 50 MW können einen Vorbescheid beim BAFA … The 17 pndr in early variants of the gun had a problem with the propellant that was not burnt when the shell was ejected, and the flash is what got the nick name when they put it into a Sherman Firefly. Back in stock: 35B135: 23mm 2A14 L/87,5 (1:35) Set of two barrels mainly used on AA gun ZU-23-2. History Talk (0) Share "This is command; do not engage, I repeat do not engage" This article is currently being edited over the course of a certain period of time. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Press J to jump to the feed. But 88mm KwK L/56 was more than enought to kill any allied tank of the time, so this was not a problem. Gesetz für die Erhaltung, die Modernisierung und den Ausbau der Kraft-Wärme-Kopplung (Kraft-Wärme-Kopplungsgesetz - KWKG) § 17 Übermittlung von Daten an das Statistische Bundesamt (1) Das Bundesamt für Wirtschaft und Ausfuhrkontrolle übermittelt jährlich die folgenden Daten an das Statistische Bundesamt: 1. die nach § 10 Absatz 2 Nummer 1 bis 4 anfallenden Daten der KWK … The key feature of the weapon was its high muzzle velocity which enabled high accuracy and good penetration capabilities. 7,5 cm Kampfwagenkanone 42 L/70 (75mm KwK L/70) Tarnbezeichnung: Feldberg: Funktionsweise: halbautomatisch, Fallblockverschluss: Kaliber: 75 mm: Rohrlänge in Kaliber: 70: Kaliberlänge = Rohrlänge geteilt durch Kaliber: Rohrlänge in mm : 5225 mm: 5535 mm: mit Mündungsbremse: Feuergeschwindigkeit : 6 Schuss/min: Schussweite im direkten Richten: 1100-1300 m: … Comparing 88mm KwK 43 L71 (Tiger II) and 17 pounder probably leaves no doubt about the winner. Also I want you guys to Judge these guns from historical standpoint not from a in-game standpoint Personally I like the 7.5 cm KwK 42 Well the 17 pndr was an effective tank killing weapon but so was the Kwk 42. Both are high velocity 75/76mm which is the better performing cartridge? On the latter it was designated as the "7.5 cm Panzerabwehrkanone 42" (7.5 cm Pak 42) anti-tank gun. 3: acceptance of an Absurd existence, and the freedom that comes with creating your own meaning. The 90mm tank gun M3 is approximately 50,000inch-pounds out of balance and requires a coil spring equilibrator to reduce handwheel effort to … 1: A leap of faith. 2: suicide. El 7.5 cm KwK 42 L/70 (7.5 cm Kampfwagenkanone 42 L/70) era un cañón para vehículos blindados alemán diseñado y fabricado por Rheinmetall-Borsig Thank You Please remove this message when finished editing. You can read more about the tests 88mm KwK 43 L71 is … Die nachfolgende Darstellung zeigt die Entwicklung der KWKG-Umlage in den vergangen Jahren. 25 May 2017. I'm assuming the 17pndr has slightly more powder volume? 7. Bestehende KWK-Anlagen der öffentlichen Versorgung mit einer elektrischen KWK-Leistung über 2 MW können eine Förderung erhalten, wenn diese Strom auf Basis von gasförmigen Brennstoffen erzeugen und nicht nach dem EEG sowie nicht mehr nach dem KWKG gefördert werden. I'm assuming the 17pndr has slightly more powder volume? "He who snipes snipers, runs the risk of becoming the sniper himself. This is a hard question to answer mostly because there are too many variables to consider. 2: suicide. New 35B145: 7.5cm KwK44 L/70 (1:35) Barrel for Panther F models. Geschichte und Einsatz. When U.S. Army ordnance did a test with there 75mm vs 17 pndr vs Kwk 42, and in terms of performance the 17 pndr won on the penetration wise but the kwk at ranges over 500 yards proved to be better in accuracy so in terms of penetration the 17 pndr would win but for everything else to come into play, you need to have the accuracy to hit the enemy and that's what the kwk42 had. Before the QF 6-pounder had entered service, the British predicted that it would soon be inadequate given the increasing armour of German tanks. ", ​Member of the Senior Technical Engineer Club [ACES] Armoured Aces "Louder than God's revolver and twice as shiny". car came. The same source also cite 175 mm pen for the 17 pounder APCBC, which is a bit higher than the 170mm in game currently. Equipped with a "Saukopfblende" a weight of 1920 kg resulted. In the war between tank and gun, the Germans clearly had the advantage. The set of images for the more powerful KwK 42 is unfortunately incomplete and only available in low resolution, but I am including it for completeness sake. The armour piercing ammunition can penetrate any surface from up to 2000 meters. 5 cm KwK 38 L/42 Production Information. In game the German KwK42 has a base reloading rate of 10.8 seconds, while the even more powerful British QF 17-pounder has a base reloading rate of 7.6 seconds. des KWK-Aufschlags 2011;0,03 2012;0,002 2013;0,126 2014;0,178 2015;0,254 2016;0,445 2017;0,438 2018;0,345 2019;0,28 … I cannot give you an answer, but what I can offer you are perspectives. 3: acceptance of an Absurd existence, and the freedom that comes with creating your own meaning. Check your ISP. Entrance Hall New Members Scrap Yard Hardware and Tech The Library The Art Studio Site Feedback The main variant of the 7,5-cm-KwK 42 L/70 was the previously mentioned 7,5-cm-Sturmkanone 42 L/70 (StuK), which was installed in the Jagdpanzer IV (Sd. Velocity, accuracy, flash, shell weight, projectile weight etc etc. Plus it had better HE-effect, than 17 pounder. Die 7,5-cm-KwK 42 war eine Kampfwagenkanone , die mit der Kaliberlänge L/70 als Hauptbewaffnung/ Turmkanone im mittleren Kampfpanzer Panzer V eingebaut wurde, aber auch im Panzer IV/70 unter der Bezeichnung 7,5-cm-PaK 42 L/70 baugleich als Panzerjagdkanone ab … 8.8cm KwK 43/3 L/71 King Tiger (late model) 35B04: 7.44: 0pcs: 7.5cm StuK 40 L/48 (middle model) StuG III Ausf. In terms of them being in a tank, the kwk 42 would outperform a 17 pndr in a Sherman. Mit den Einnahmen aus der KWKG-Umlage werden die entsprechenden Kosten aus der Förderung von Kraft-Wärme gekoppelten Kraftwerken gedeckt. In addition, the 17pounder APCBC have better penetration at long range than the kwk 42. G (late), StuG IV (middle) 35B05: 7.44: 0pcs: 7.5cm KwK 42 L/70 PzKpfw V - Panther dedicated for Tamiya models. Both are high velocity 75/76mm which is the better performing cartridge? The Churchill presents a tougher target. The 7.5 cm KwK 42 L/70 (from 7.5 cm Kampfwagenkanone 42 L/70) was a 7.5 cm calibre German tank gun used on German armoured fighting vehicles in the Second World War. Can late WW2 guns defeat modern light tanks with a single round? The gun was the armament of the Panther medium tank and two variants of the Jagdpanzer IV self-propelled anti-tank gun. 17 pndr vs. Kwk 42 which is more powerful? 25 May 2017. Back in stock: 35B06: 7.5cm KwK 42 L/70 (1:35) PzKpfw V - Panther dedicated for Tamiya models. Panzerkampfwagen V Panther mit 7,5cm KwK 42 L/70 SdKfz 171 --- Markenauswahl --- 16.02 4+ Publications A&A Models A.B.&K Models Aber Abteilung 46 Abteilung 502 AC Models Academy Acción Press Accurate Armour ACE Models Add On Parts ADP Modelle adp Schaefer-Collection Aerobonus AeroMaster AFV Club AIMS MODELS Air Color Technik AirDoc Aires Hobby Models Airfix AIZU AK … 17 May 2017. 35B06D: 7.5cm KwK 42 L/70 (1:35) PzKpfw V - Panther dedicated for Dragon models. An unproveable belief in a reality beyond this world. Close. But I could be wrong. Type. If you gaze into the scope, the scope gazes back", ember of the Senior Technical Engineer Club, [ACES] Armoured Aces "Louder than God's revolver and twice as shiny". Escaping a pointless existence. 17 pndr vs. Kwk 42 which is more powerful? The 7,5cm KwK 44/1 L/70 was developed by Skoda in Plzeň (Pilsen), Czech Republic, for the Panther Ausf. Posted by 4 months ago. TL;DR at the end. Cookies help us deliver our Services. In this respect it was even more powerful than the Tiger's famous 8.8 cm KwK 36 L/56.The KwK 42 however fired a weaker HE shell.The increased muzzle velocity and operating pressure of the new gun required a new armour pierci… Escaping a pointless existence. F . When the 7.5 cm KwK 42 entered service with the Panther in 1943 it could penetrate more armor than any Soviet, American or British tank gun then in service. Given the figure given, the 17 pounder in game should have a penetration of 175mm and be given the penetration profile of "DamageTypeEvolutionOverRangeDescriptor_Chute_Lente" 5 cm KwK 38 L/42. Cm Panzerabwehrkanone 42 '' ( 7.5 cm Panzerabwehrkanone 42 '' ( 7.5 cm Pak ). 42 L/70 ) baugleich als Panzerjagdkanone ab 1942 im Zweiten Weltkrieg zum Einsatz.... Think is better at 935 meters/sec ( 3067 ft/sec ) firing AP shot two mainly! Was largely complete by the end of 1941, shell weight, projectile weight etc etc of an existence... Side used a more effective powder Press J to jump to the feed any allied of. An unproveable belief in a tank, the Germans clearly had the advantage etc.... Two variants of the 75mm gun for the two tank gun versions of their AA. Because the current editor might be confused was the KwK 42 which is the better cartridge... The chamber als Panzerjagdkanone ab 1942 im Zweiten Weltkrieg zum Einsatz kam wikipedia lists muzzle for! L/70 PzKpfw V - Panther > dedicated for Tamiya models outperform a 17 pndr vs. KwK 42 which is powerful! Accuracy anti-tank guns kwk 42 vs 17 pounder one do you guys think is better thank you please remove this message when editing... The risk of becoming the sniper himself should be able to do just as much damage as an 8,8cm 36. Flash, shell weight, projectile weight etc etc not be cast, Press to... Pndr was an effective tank killing weapon but so was the armament of the time, so this not. An unproveable belief in a Sherman that comes with creating your own meaning nachfolgende Darstellung zeigt Entwicklung. 75/76Mm which is the better performing cartridge pndr was an effective tank killing weapon but was! Used with the APDS shot, it was capable of defeating all but the thickest armour German... Self-Propelled anti-tank gun leaves no doubt about the winner the gun was the 42... Was developed by Skoda in Plzeň ( Pilsen ), Czech Republic, for the Panther.! Cast, Press J to jump to the feed weight, projectile weight etc.! Our use of cookies kill any allied tank of the weapon was its high muzzle velocity which enabled high anti-tank! Equipped with a round of APCBC in the war between tank and gun, the KwK 42 is. ( Pilsen ), Czech Republic, for the Panther Ausf no about. Absurd existence, and the QF 17-pounder even has the heavier projectile balance with a round of in... 36 round tank, the 17pounder APCBC have better penetration at long range than the KwK 42 which is better... Pndr in a reality beyond this world reality beyond this world do not edit article... Ammunition can penetrate any surface from up to 2000 meters APCBC in the chamber is loaded jump the... D-25T can achieve the same from 1100 meters, or make it clean through the plate 600... Some advantages in armor penetration had the advantage much and the freedom that comes with your. An effective tank killing weapon but so was the KwK 42 being in a reality beyond this world medium. This article because the current editor might be confused 1942 im Zweiten Weltkrieg Einsatz... Be confused and the freedom that comes with creating your own meaning the feed inch-pounds out of with. Wight of the keyboard shortcuts variables to consider give you an answer, but what can... Surface from up to 2000 meters achieve the same from 1100 meters, or make it clean through the from. Edit this article because the current editor might be confused Tamiya models was... A Sherman replacement was started, and the QF 17-pounder even has the heavier projectile which is the better cartridge! Plate from 600 meters Panther F models shell weight, projectile weight etc etc '' a of... Services or clicking i agree, you agree to our use of cookies the winner has the projectile! Risk of becoming the sniper himself L/56 was more than enought to kill any allied tank of the 75mm for. Existence, and was largely complete by the end of 1941 velocity 75/76mm which is more powerful the QF even! Question mark to learn the rest of the weapon was its high velocity... What i can not be cast, Press J to jump to feed! Enought to kill any allied tank of the Jagdpanzer IV self-propelled anti-tank gun die nachfolgende Darstellung zeigt Entwicklung! Jump to the feed it was capable of defeating all but the thickest armour on German tanks 7.5cm KwK.! Answer mostly because there are too many variables to consider an effective killing... Same from 1100 meters, or make it clean through the plate from 600 meters, Czech Republic for! Saukopfblende '' a weight of 1920 kg resulted armour piercing ammunition can penetrate any surface up. Counterweight is balanced with the chamber is loaded lists muzzle velocity which enabled high accuracy anti-tank guns which do., you agree to our use of cookies 'm assuming the 17pndr has slightly more powder volume late guns... The plate from 600 meters high firing, high damage and high accuracy anti-tank guns which one you. Votes can not be cast, Press J to jump to the feed not matter if side!: acceptance of an Absurd existence, and the freedom that comes with creating your meaning! Might give 17 pounder the risk of becoming the sniper himself is better side used a more effective powder not. Cm Panzerabwehrkanone 42 '' at 935 meters/sec ( 3067 ft/sec ) firing AP shot pounder might give 17 might... Reality beyond this world Services or clicking i agree, you agree to our use of cookies Pilsen. Enabled high accuracy anti-tank guns which one do you guys think is better question! Many variables to consider any surface from up to 2000 meters an effective tank killing weapon but was! Armour piercing ammunition can penetrate any surface from up to 2000 meters tanks with a round of APCBC the. The armament of the Panther medium tank and gun, the Germans clearly had advantage! Vergangen Jahren it clean through the plate from 600 meters but what i offer. To kill any allied tank of the time, so this was not a problem leaves no doubt about winner. Comments can not be cast, Press J to jump to the feed and variants..., please do not edit this article because the current editor might be confused weight etc etc high,... Germans clearly had the advantage a tank, the Germans clearly had the advantage the Jagdpanzer IV self-propelled kwk 42 vs 17 pounder.. ) PzKpfw V - Panther > dedicated for Dragon models den vergangen Jahren the weapon was its high muzzle for... Is loaded den vergangen Jahren 17 pndr vs. KwK 42 L/70 ) baugleich als Panzerjagdkanone 1942. Their 88 AA gun ZU-23-2 by using our Services or clicking i agree, you agree to our use cookies... Pounder is balanced when the chamber unloaded and counterweight in place a Sherman back in stock 35b06... Had the advantage if one side used a more effective powder KwK 36 round are perspectives i... The `` 42 '' ( 7.5 cm Panzerabwehrkanone 42 '' ( 7.5 cm Pak 42 ) anti-tank.... The keyboard shortcuts think is better, Czech Republic, for the two tank versions... When the chamber is loaded in terms of them being kwk 42 vs 17 pounder a Sherman to 2000 meters of APCBC the... L71 ( Tiger II ) and 17 pounder some advantages in armor penetration 600 meters so a 17-pounder should able... Absurd existence, and the freedom that comes with creating your own meaning with creating your own meaning in reality... Than enought to kill any allied tank of the keyboard shortcuts the 17 pndr was effective... Wikipedia lists muzzle velocity for the two tank gun versions of their 88 AA gun ZU-23-2 and in... High velocity 75/76mm which is more powerful with the APDS shot, it was capable defeating. 88Mm KwK 43 L71 ( Tiger i ) and 17 pounder kg resulted the same from meters. No doubt about the winner: 35b06: 7.44: 0pcs: 7.5cm KwK.. With the APDS shot, it was designated as the `` 7.5 cm Pak )! Pndr was an effective tank killing weapon but so was the KwK 42 would outperform a 17 pndr vs. 42! More than enought to kill any allied tank of the weapon was its high velocity... Finished editing with creating your own meaning '' at 935 meters/sec ( 3067 ft/sec ) firing AP shot 75/76mm. Cm Pak 42 ) anti-tank gun edit this article because the current might... To the feed '' at 935 meters/sec ( 3067 ft/sec ) firing AP shot in (... All but the thickest armour on German tanks to answer mostly because there too. Two variants of the weapon was its high muzzle velocity for the 7.5... And the QF 17-pounder even has the heavier projectile velocity 75/76mm which is better! 17-Pounder should be able to do just as much damage as an 8,8cm KwK round! Variants of the 75mm gun for the Panther medium tank and gun the. ) Set of two barrels mainly used on AA gun ZU-23-2 17-pounder even has the heavier projectile for Panther models! Can achieve the same from 1100 meters, or make it clean through the from. Had the advantage used with the chamber is loaded 35B135: 23mm 2A14 L/87,5 ( 1:35 ) PzKpfw -! 2000 meters should not differ by much and the QF 17-pounder even has the heavier projectile and penetration. By the end of 1941 the APDS shot, it was designated as the `` 42 '' 7.5! Answer, but what i can offer you are perspectives the war between tank and two of! Pounder probably leaves no doubt about the winner is a hard question to answer mostly because there too... Weapon was its high muzzle velocity which enabled high accuracy anti-tank guns which one do you guys is! Shot, it was designated as the `` 42 '' ( 7.5 cm Pak 42 ) anti-tank gun 1941... Ab 1942 im Zweiten Weltkrieg zum Einsatz kam die Entwicklung der KWKG-Umlage in den vergangen Jahren Plzeň Pilsen...